Skip to content
Medical billing

How to Choose a Revenue Cycle Management Company: 12 Questions to Ask

Choose the revenue cycle management (RCM) company that fits your practice on four things: it has worked your specialty and your payers, it can show you how it works a claim from the eligibility check to the last payment, it reports the same few numbers to you every month, and its contract lets you leave with your data. Price matters too, but only once you know that two quotes buy the same work. Our guide to what medical billing companies charge covers that side.

Most practices compare RCM companies on the sales call and the rate. The questions below get at what a sales call tends to skip: who will actually work your claims, what happens to a denial, and what you'll see each month.

Before you call anyone: know your own numbers

Pull three numbers from your practice management system for the last three months. They are your starting point, and the only way to judge what any company tells you.

  • Your denial rate: claims denied, divided by claims the payers answered.
  • Your A/R by age: how much is still owed 0–30, 31–60, 61–90, 91–120 and over 120 days after the date of service.
  • Your days in A/R: your total A/R divided by your average daily charges. It shows roughly how many days of billing are waiting to be paid.

If you can't pull these, that's worth knowing too. A careful RCM company will ask for them, or for the reports they come from, before it quotes.

Decide what you're handing over

"Revenue cycle management" can mean the whole path from the eligibility check to the last patient payment, or only claims and payments. Write down which stages you want covered, then ask each company about each one by name. Our revenue cycle management guide walks through every stage.

Stage

What it covers

Ask

Eligibility and benefits

Checking coverage before the visit

Before every visit, or only for new patients?

Coding

Assigning CPT, ICD-10-CM and HCPCS codes

From the provider's notes, or entering codes your providers pick?

Charges and claims

Building, scrubbing and sending claims

Which clearinghouse, and who fixes a rejected claim?

Payment posting

Posting ERAs and EOBs to each claim

Do they check each payment against your contracted rate?

Denials and appeals

Correcting or appealing denied claims

Is every denial worked, or only those above a dollar amount?

A/R follow-up

Chasing claims the payer hasn't paid

How often is each unpaid claim checked?

Patient balances

Statements and patients' billing calls

Who answers your patients' questions about a bill?

Credentialing

Payer enrollment and revalidation

Included, or priced separately?

You don't have to hand over everything. Some practices keep the front desk and coding in-house and outsource only the stages that are slipping.

The 12 questions to ask an RCM company

Fit

1. Which practices like ours do you bill for now? Specialty, size and state all change the work. A good answer names the codes, modifiers and payer rules that cause denials in your specialty. "We do every specialty" isn't an answer. You can see the specialties we work with on our specialties page.

2. Which of our payers do you know well? Your Medicare Administrative Contractor, your state's Medicaid plans and your largest commercial payers each have their own rules and portals. A good company asks for your payer mix before it quotes, because that mix shapes how much work your claims will need.

3. Will you work in our systems, or move us to yours? Some companies work in your practice management system and EHR; others move you to their own software. Either can work. What matters is that you keep your own login and can see your claims, payments and A/R whenever you want, without asking.

How they work your claims

4. Who will work our account, and who do we call? Ask for a named contact, how many other practices that person handles, and how you'll reach them when a payer stops paying. You want someone who knows your account, not a general inbox.

5. What happens to a denied claim, step by step? A good answer: each denial is logged by its reason code, corrected or appealed before the payer's deadline, and its cause is fixed upstream so it doesn't come back. Ask whether small balances are ever written off without your say. Our denial management tips show what that process looks like inside a practice.

6. How do you follow up claims the payer hasn't answered? Unpaid claims don't chase themselves. Ask how often each open claim is checked, by portal or by phone, and what happens as it ages toward the payer's filing limit. Our A/R follow-up page shows how we sort that work by age and value.

7. What will you need from us, and how quickly? A billing company can only bill what it receives: charges, the provider's notes, insurance cards and referrals. Ask what it needs from your staff each day, and what happens when a note doesn't support the code. The HHS Office of Inspector General's compliance guidance for third-party billing companies expects a billing company to get clarification from the provider when documentation is confusing or doesn't justify the claim, not to guess.

Reporting

8. Which numbers will you report every month, and how do you calculate them? Ask to see a sample report with the names removed. Then ask how each number is calculated, because the same name can hide different math. The Healthcare Financial Management Association publishes standard definitions for most of them, its MAP Keys. These are the numbers worth seeing each month:

Number

What it tells you

How it's calculated

Denial rate

How often payers turn claims down

Claims denied ÷ claims remitted. HFMA leaves out patient-responsibility and non-covered denials, and duplicates

Clean claim rate

How many claims go out right the first time

Claims that pass the scrubber's edits with no manual fix ÷ claims scrubbed

Days in A/R

How long money takes to come in

HFMA: net A/R ÷ average daily net revenue over the last three months. Many practices use total A/R and gross charges, so ask which

A/R by age

How much of what's owed is getting old

Billed A/R in each band (0–30 days through over 120), from the date of service, as a share of the total

Net collection rate

How much of what you're owed you actually collect

Payments ÷ (charges − contractual adjustments). Not an HFMA key; also called the adjusted collection rate

Watch the trend more than any single month. Our reporting and analytics page shows what a monthly report should cover.

9. Can we see our own claims at any time? A good answer is yes, in your system or with read-only access to theirs. Reports are a summary; being able to look up any claim yourself is how you check them.

Compliance and the contract

10. Will you sign a business associate agreement, and can we see your compliance program? A company that handles patient information to bill for you is a business associate under HIPAA, and 45 CFR 164.502(e) requires a written agreement with it. Its compliance program matters as much. OIG's guidance for billing companies lists seven elements: written standards of conduct, a compliance officer, training, a way to report problems, a process for responding to them, audits, and correcting what the audits find. The same guidance says a billing company should send a copy of its compliance program to every provider client, so asking for one is a reasonable request.

11. If a claim is wrong, who is responsible? You are. When a practice bills Medicare electronically, it signs an EDI enrollment agreement in which it agrees to be responsible for all Medicare claims submitted by itself, its employees or its agents. So ask how the company checks its own coding, and what it does when it finds an overpayment. OIG's guidance expects billing companies to report overpayments to both the provider and the health program, and to share audit results with their clients.

12. What happens if we leave? Ask about the notice period, who works the claims already sent, and how your claims, payment and A/R history come back to you, and in what format. The business associate agreement must also say what happens to patient information when the contract ends. Our pricing guide lists the contract terms to read before you sign.

Red flags

  • A promised result before they've seen your numbers. Nobody can tell you how much more you'll collect without looking at your denials and your A/R first.
  • Numbers without definitions. A clean claim rate means little until you know what counts as clean.
  • No sample report, or no way to see your own claims.
  • Hesitation over a business associate agreement, or over putting the return of your data in the contract.
  • A fee on money they didn't work, such as a percentage of payments your front desk collects, unless that's what you agreed to.
  • "We do every specialty" with no examples of your codes or your payers.

A scorecard for comparing RCM companies

Score each company from 1 to 5 on each line, multiply by the weight, and add up the column. Change the weights to fit what matters most to your practice.

What you're scoring

Weight

Company A

Company B

Company C

Experience with your specialty and payers

3




How they work denials and unpaid claims

3




Monthly reports, with definitions

3




Your access to your own claims and data

2




Business associate agreement and compliance program

2




Contract: term, notice and data return

2




Effective rate for the same scope of work

2




A named contact who knows your account

1




For the effective rate, divide each company's yearly fee by your yearly collections, for the same list of stages. Our pricing guide shows the arithmetic with three sample quotes.

Where Beeline fits

Beeline is a US company with a dedicated billing team. In a free consultation, we'll answer these questions for your own practice, starting from your summary reports, with no patient information needed. You can hand over the whole revenue cycle, only the stages that are slipping, or nothing at all.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a revenue cycle management company do?

It handles the work between a patient's visit and the last payment: checking coverage, coding, sending claims, posting payments, working denials and following up claims that haven't been paid. Some also handle credentialing and patient statements.

What's the difference between a medical billing company and an RCM company?

Often only the name. "Medical billing" sometimes means claims and payments only, while "revenue cycle management" covers everything from the eligibility check to the last collection. Ask which stages a company covers rather than going by its label.

How much do revenue cycle management companies charge?

Most charge a percentage of collections, a fee per claim or a flat monthly fee. Compare quotes by their effective rate, the yearly fee divided by yearly collections, for the same scope of work.

Do we need a business associate agreement with an RCM company?

Yes. HIPAA treats a company that handles patient information to bill for you as a business associate, and requires a written business associate agreement with it.

Are we responsible for claims an RCM company sends for us?

Yes. For Medicare, a practice that bills electronically agrees in its EDI enrollment agreement to be responsible for claims its agents submit. That's why it pays to ask how a company checks its coding.

Can we outsource only part of our revenue cycle?

Yes. Agree in writing which stages the company covers, and who does each of the others, so nothing falls between you.

Find out where your billing stands.

Unsure how much revenue you are missing? Start with a complimentary billing audit.

Free consultation